The dart has 25k miles on it. Front bumper damage. Rebuilt tilte.
The Vipe has 94k miles on it. Clean title.
Both same price around $8k.
Reliability and Good MPG is very important to me.
I live in Michigan (so lots of snow and rain) and I m a working student (drive about 1-2 hours everyday).
The dart is basically a Fiat, so let your conscience be your guide. Pontiac no longer exists and the Vibe was not a good car to begin with. I'd keep looking.
Dodge Dart. And not only because of its look. The Dart has achieved what's essentially a bulls-eye in U.S. crash-test ratings--with top five-star ratings overall from the federal government and Top Safety Pick status from the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety. That combination makes it one of the highest-rated cars for safety in this class--next to only the Honda Civic. It offers a lot of space, features and style for the money.
2014 Dodge Dart. Neither one is as good as the Japanese or even Korean counterparts. However, if you don't have a choice, the newer the better.
The Dart looks waaaay better than the Vibe, so I recommend you get the Dart.
Of your two the Dart.